REIT Distributions are NOT Dividends and This Matters
I use the words "dividend" and "distribution" interchangeably on this blog. That's a bad habit, and I want to fix it because the difference has real tax consequences.
Dividends vs. Distributions
Dividends, specifically eligible dividends from Canadian public companies, are paid out of after-tax corporate profits. By the time that money hits your account, the company has already paid tax on it. You're only on the hook for personal tax, and Canada's dividend tax credit softens that further.
Distributions are a different animal. REITs are structured as trusts, not corporations, which means they pass income directly to you without paying much, or any, corporate tax first. That sounds great until you realize distributions are made up of multiple components like rental income, capital gains, return of capital, and sometimes foreign income, each taxed at a different rate. The exact breakdown varies by REIT and changes year to year. Come tax time, you need to sort through the T3 slip and apply the right rate to each piece.
Return of capital is worth calling out specifically. It's not immediately taxable, but it reduces your adjusted cost base, which means a larger capital gain when you eventually sell. It's not free money. It is deferred tax.
Where to Hold REITs
This complexity is exactly why TFSAs are the ideal home for REITs. Inside a TFSA, none of this matters. The components, the T3, the adjusted cost base - they are all irrelevant. A 6% distribution on a $10,000 position is $600 in your pocket, no tax, no paperwork.
RRSPs work too, and there's nothing wrong with holding REITs there. Just know that withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income, so the distribution composition doesn't matter going in but your marginal rate will matter coming out.
Non-registered accounts are the most complicated. You'll need to track each distribution component annually and report them correctly. Doable, but it's real paperwork, and the tax drag on rental income (taxed at your marginal rate) can be significant.
If you're building a REIT position and have TFSA room, fill that first. It's the cleanest, most tax-efficient place to let distributions compound. And this is why you hear so many people recommending TFSAs for REITs.